Lucy's Pizza
Lucy's Pizza, located at 26 S Highland Ave in Ossining, NY, has become a staple in the local community, serving up delicious and authentic New York-style pizza for years. With its casual atmosphere and a menu full of beloved dishes, this pizzeria offers more than just a slice of pizza—it’s a neighborhood favorite with something for everyone.
Menu Highlights at Lucy's Pizza
Lucy's Pizza is known for its classic pizza options, with the Cheese Pizza being the star of the show. The pizza crust is perfectly crispy, and the cheese is melted to perfection, offering that quintessential New York-style pizza experience. Another crowd favorite is the Focaccia Pizza, which adds a unique twist with a slightly thicker and fluffier base, topped with delicious ingredients. For those who enjoy a filling meal, the Cheese Calzone is an excellent choice—stuffed with gooey cheese and baked to golden perfection. To complement your meal, Lucy's also offers crispy French Fries and a fresh Tossed Salad, making it a well-rounded dining experience. Whether you're craving a quick slice or a full meal, Lucy's Pizza caters to all tastes with its extensive and flavorful menu.
Services and Dining Experience
Lucy's Pizza goes above and beyond to provide a variety of services that make dining here convenient and enjoyable. They offer delivery and takeout for those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home. If you're planning to dine in, they also take reservations to accommodate larger groups or special occasions. The restaurant has several vegan and vegetarian options, ensuring there's something for everyone, regardless of dietary preferences.
For those who like to enjoy a laid-back atmosphere, Lucy's Pizza is a casual spot with a moderate noise level, making it great for both lunch and dinner. The restaurant offers outdoor seating, ideal for dining on a sunny day, and there's even Wi-Fi for those who need to work while they eat. Street parking is available, and they also offer bike parking, making it convenient for all types of visitors.
Families will appreciate the restaurant's kid-friendly environment, and it's also a great choice for group gatherings. Waiter service is available, and the staff is known for being friendly and efficient, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. For those who enjoy a drink with their meal, Lucy's Pizza serves alcohol, making it a great spot to unwind with a beer or wine.
Positive Customer Experiences
Customers consistently praise Lucy's Pizza for its delicious food and friendly service. One regular, Harry R., describes the restaurant as a staple in the Ossining community, with its consistent quality in pizza, wings, sandwiches, and pasta. He highlights Lucy's as a go-to spot for takeout, thanks to its quick service and satisfying meals.
Kathryn K., another satisfied customer, raves about Lucy's eggplant pizza, which she calls the best she's ever had. Unlike most places, the eggplant isn't breaded, giving it a fresh and authentic taste that stands out. She also appreciates the quick turnaround time, with pies typically ready in just 20 minutes.
Ashley E. shares a similar sentiment, noting that Lucy's Pizza is a quick and easy option for lunch, especially if you're in the area. She appreciates the NY-style pizza and the convenience of getting both slices and made-to-order pizzas, along with pastas and subs. The service is quick, and while you might have to wait a bit if dining in, the staff ensures you're taken care of when your order is ready.
Lucy's Pizza excels in offering a consistent and high-quality dining experience, whether you’re dining in or ordering out. The combination of classic pizza offerings, welcoming atmosphere, and thoughtful services makes it a standout choice for anyone in the Ossining area. Whether you're craving a classic slice or exploring new flavors, Lucy's Pizza provides an inviting and dependable option for all.
Reviews
I just love their eggplant pizza!! I am a bit of an eggplant snob, and there is the best. No breading at all, most places are all breading. Pies are usually done in 20 minutes ,fresh, hot and delicious!!!
Quick and easy lunch if you're in the area! Lucy's is just a local NY style pizza joint, but in addition to grab & go slices that also have pizzas made to order, pastas and subs. Staff was nice and service was quick. They aren't in a rush to ring you up if you're dining in, so just order relax and they'll take care of you when your order is ready. Can't speak to the take out experience but people were popping in and out without issues it seemed. Clean and well lit place, small and minimal seating though. Seems more of a takeout place than a sit and enjoy there kind of place. There is a parking lot in the back and some parking on the street, but I could see it being an issue if other places around are busy too depending on the time.
Lucy's has been a staple in Ossining for several years. A great place to go where you can get solid slice of pizza! Local fan favorite. The staff is always welcoming and prices are good. I would normally give Lucy's five stars but I am a little bummed. The last two times I have been there, the pizza just wasn't the same as I grew up with. Slices were more doughy and a little thinker than that thin slice we grew up with. Who knows. But it still remains my number one choice for pizza in Ossining!! Will keep on going. Maybe a fluke. lol. But still tops for me!!!
I love coming here! Food is always good and staff is nice! The place is clean, organized and vibes are good! The icees are always in high demand cause they're so good. Definitely my go-to pizza spot.
Lucy is a staple in the Ossining community. Located just across the street from Ossining high school, these guys know how to do it old school and just about right from pizza to wings to sandwiches and pasta. You could find what you need at Lucy's great for takeout